Clarytrade
15 brokers indexedcommission weighted 0%
Costs and fees

Spread-only vs raw-spread accounts: which is cheaper?

Raw-spread plus commission isn't automatically cheaper than a wider spread with no commission. How to work out which fits how you trade.

Updated 18 Jun 2026 · 5 min readBy the Clarytrade editorial team · How we check facts

Most brokers offer two account styles for the same markets. Picking the wrong one quietly costs you money on every trade. Neither is "cheaper" in the abstract — it depends on how you trade.

The two models

  • Spread-only (standard) account. No separate commission. The cost is baked into a wider spread — say 1.2 pips on EUR/USD.
  • Raw-spread (ECN) account. A much tighter spread — often near 0.0–0.3 pips — plus a fixed commission per lot (commonly around $3 per side, $6 round turn).

Both are charging you for the same thing. They just split it differently.

Working out which is cheaper for you

Convert both to the same unit. On EUR/USD, 1 pip on a standard lot is roughly $10, and a typical round-turn commission of $6 is about 0.6 pips.

  • Raw account: 0.2 pip spread + 0.6 pip commission ≈ 0.8 pips all-in.
  • Standard account: 1.2 pips all-in, nothing extra.

In that example the raw account is cheaper. But flip the numbers — a broker with very tight standard spreads and high commission — and the standard account can win. Do the arithmetic with the actual broker's figures.

Rules of thumb

  • Trade often / large size? Commission is a per-lot cost, but raw spreads are so much tighter that active traders usually come out ahead on a raw account.
  • Trade rarely / small size? A spread-only account is simpler and the commission saving is marginal.

The catch

Headline raw spreads ("from 0.0 pips") are best-case snapshots. Real average spreads — especially around news and at the daily rollover — are what you actually pay. Compare typical spreads, not the marketing minimum.

See the all-in cost comparison to model both. Figures are indicative; verify with the broker. Educational content, not financial advice.

Related broker checks

Ready to compare platforms?

Put this into practice — get matched in three minutes.

Match me

Educational content only. Not financial advice. Trading carries risk. Read the risk guide.